Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
+3
Big_Al_Smith
David2010
wcrocker
7 posters
Page 1 of 1
Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
Having not driven a car with the sliding windows, what are pros and cons of each type? What do people prefer?
wcrocker- Posts : 43
Points : 4808
Join date : 2011-03-25
Location : Dartmouth, Nova Scotia
SLIDING WINDOWS V ROLL UP :
Sliding windows : FOR = generous storage available in lower door compartments :
AGAINST = don't even think of visiting an automated (rotating brush) car wash !!
= the external driver's door hinges over time wear and start to droop - drivers door needs regular re-alignment.
= a Mini's sliding windows can be opened by a thief in seconds using a steel ruler or similar implement.
Roll up windows : FOR = door hinges last longer & door alignment therefore is not a recurring problem.
= automated car washes not a problem (i.e.that does not mean that your car can't be damaged - but not flooded).
= windows can be opened by a car thief but are more challenging than the simple sliding window.
AGAINST = very limited storage room in doors.
Having said all of the above, I must confess to a personal preference for the Mk.I & Mk.II Elf & Hornet.
You see, over time you can perfect the exact amount to open the leading &/or trailing window on your (driver's side) to give the car a unique & very acceptable brand of fresh-air conditioning.
David2010
AGAINST = don't even think of visiting an automated (rotating brush) car wash !!
= the external driver's door hinges over time wear and start to droop - drivers door needs regular re-alignment.
= a Mini's sliding windows can be opened by a thief in seconds using a steel ruler or similar implement.
Roll up windows : FOR = door hinges last longer & door alignment therefore is not a recurring problem.
= automated car washes not a problem (i.e.that does not mean that your car can't be damaged - but not flooded).
= windows can be opened by a car thief but are more challenging than the simple sliding window.
AGAINST = very limited storage room in doors.
Having said all of the above, I must confess to a personal preference for the Mk.I & Mk.II Elf & Hornet.
You see, over time you can perfect the exact amount to open the leading &/or trailing window on your (driver's side) to give the car a unique & very acceptable brand of fresh-air conditioning.
David2010
David2010- Posts : 231
Points : 5191
Join date : 2010-11-22
Age : 80
Location : Dublin, Ireland
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
Do the sliding windows make much noise when closed? open? I'm guessing there are ways to mitigate the security concerns? Do they leak in regular rain storms?
wcrocker- Posts : 43
Points : 4808
Join date : 2011-03-25
Location : Dartmouth, Nova Scotia
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
I always liked the sliding windows as thats what the original minis were designed with to maximise the space.
snowman- Posts : 11
Points : 3895
Join date : 2013-08-10
Location : Durham UK
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
I always felt a need to open the sliding windows ALL THE WAY!! Unfortunately...that isnt' possible. Sometimes opening a window half way...isn't enough!!!
Captain61- Posts : 42
Points : 4320
Join date : 2012-07-31
Age : 72
Location : New Jersey, USA
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
Exactly, even Issigonis himself never like the change to wind ups. The first incarnation of the Mini was like a tardis and needed little improvement. As for noise and security, not really an issue with Minis, they're all noisy and easy to nik !snowman wrote:I always liked the sliding windows as thats what the original minis were designed with to maximise the space.
Toga- Posts : 86
Points : 4851
Join date : 2011-03-24
Location : Oooop North in Cheshire
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
being only 5'4" tall, I don't think I would really need the extra space provided by sliding windows.
wcrocker- Posts : 43
Points : 4808
Join date : 2011-03-25
Location : Dartmouth, Nova Scotia
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
Depends how wide you are
snowman- Posts : 11
Points : 3895
Join date : 2013-08-10
Location : Durham UK
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
One of my reasons for dislike of the English style roll-up windows is something that won't bother you. The taller you are (i.e., the farther back you sit) the more likely you are to take a beating from the incoming wind when the windows are rolled down and you're driving at moderate to high speeds. One can get very good ventilation with sliders without that problem.
cheleker- Posts : 185
Points : 5229
Join date : 2010-06-15
Location : Seattle, Washington, USA
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
Heh heh, nice one. Fortunately, I'm not excessively wide.snowman wrote:Depends how wide you are
wcrocker- Posts : 43
Points : 4808
Join date : 2011-03-25
Location : Dartmouth, Nova Scotia
Re: Sliding Windows vs. Roll Up
That likely wouldn't be a problem for me. Whenever I take my daily drive in for service at the garage, the seat is always adjusted back.cheleker wrote:One of my reasons for dislike of the English style roll-up windows is something that won't bother you. The taller you are (i.e., the farther back you sit) the more likely you are to take a beating from the incoming wind when the windows are rolled down and you're driving at moderate to high speeds. One can get very good ventilation with sliders without that problem.
wcrocker- Posts : 43
Points : 4808
Join date : 2011-03-25
Location : Dartmouth, Nova Scotia
Similar topics
» A little more Security for Sliding windows.
» Rock n Roll & ska
» Sliding Window channel replacement
» Nasty wind up windows
» rear opening windows
» Rock n Roll & ska
» Sliding Window channel replacement
» Nasty wind up windows
» rear opening windows
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|